Despite holding two manors and enjoying considerable status, John was no angel. The list of his misdemeanours is lengthy, varied, and extensively documented in the Wakefield Court Rolls. His appearances for trespass are as follows:
1418 John Stansfield son of Ralph gentleman, trespass and hunting (
CP40 #629)
6 May 1434 Hipperholme, trespass
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)12 Oct 1434 Hipperholme, trespass
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)13 Nov 1434 Hipperholme, trespass WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
10 Dec 1434 Hipperholme, trespass WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
14 Jan 1435 Hipperholme, trespass WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
11 Feb 1435 probably Hipperholme WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
4 Mar 1435 Hipperholme, trespass
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)25 Mar 1435 Hipperholme, trespass
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)22 Apr 1435 Hipperholme, trespass WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
5 Jun 1435 Hipperholme, trespass WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
29 Aug 1439 Hipperholme. Suit between William Sharpp, plaintiff, and John Stancefeld, defendant. Plea of Trespass (
History of the Family of Stansfeld p124)
And along the same lines:
19 Jun 1435 Hipperholme, sheep on common WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
John also appeared for assault on two occasions:
5 Oct 1416 Halifax Tourn. The panel present Ralph Stansfeld, John Stansfeld, John son of Ralph Stansfeld and R—(torn) Stansfeld, for making, at Halifax, on the 27th August, 4th Henry V [1416] an assault upon Richard Horrneclif and Thomas Horrneclif, shooting at them and drawing blood from the same Richard, and making a great affray. They are ordered to be attached.
The following can also be found, but this is probably John's uncle, also called John:
1424 Halifax Tourn. John Stansfeld of Sourbybrig (Sowerby Bridge) attached for an assault made on Sunday next after the Feast of the Ascension of our Lord, 2 Henry VI, on John Rigmayden and for a great affray against the peace.
John also sought wood and turf on other people's land:
1429 John Stansfeld amerced for cutting wood
History of the Family of Stansfeld p12412 Oct 1434 Northowram, cutting turf WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
19 Oct 1435 Northowram, cutting turf WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436)
19 Sept 1437 amerced for cutting underwood in Brynescoles, Hipperholme
24 April 1438 amerced for cutting underwood in Brynescoles, Hipperholme
22 April 1440 presented for cutting wood in Brynescoles, Hipperholme
Evidently, John felt able to defend himself on occasion as he is twice recorded as 'wagering his law' in court*:
1435 at Hipperholme, John Stansfield wagered his law
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436) p11829 July 1435 John Stansfield wagered his law
WCR (YAS) vol 15 (1433-1436) p121*A defendant who elected to "wager his law" was permitted to make a statement, swear an oath that it was true, and present one or more individuals who swore that they believed he had told the truth under oath. This was the predominant form of defense in feudal courts,
Finally, at odds with his extensive record, he also served as a juror in one case:
13 Mar and 6 Jun 1431 at Wakefield, listed under Hipperholme, John Stansfeld was a juror in a suit between Richard Prestelay, plaintiff, and William Brodele, defendant.